Verification Theatre: When Facts Stop Mattering

Jason Arday stepped down from his chair at the University of Cambridge earlier this week, following weeks of reporting by The Telegraph and The Times, and just hours after the university opened an investigation into his academic qualifications and honorary appointments.

Questions have been raised about the qualifications he held and where he earned them, about books he said he had written, about places he said he had been, and about television programmes said to have featured him. The claims that built his academic career are being checked, and a striking number of them do not stand up to scrutiny.

For fairness, Arday denies wrongdoing and attributes errors in early work to inadequate supervision and his disabilities, and I have no interest in kicking a clearly troubled man who has just lost so much. The interesting question is not about him at all. It is this: how did the most famous verification institution in the world fail to verify?

That is what a university is. Strip away the gowns and gothic spires and Cambridge's core product - for hundreds of years -, has been certification: this person's work has been examined, and it is real. That is what the degree says. It is the entire economic function of the place. And yet a professorship was awarded, honorary doctorates followed from five other universities, and the checking, when it finally happened, was done by a Substack and two newspapers. The institution built to examine work took three years from first written warning to first investigation, and then the man resigned before it concluded.

… Continue reading the full article at the original source below.